Fulfyld
Get a free quote Call (256) 716-8241
Fulfillment Benchmarks

Real fulfillment costs & data — by category

Verified pricing, compliance requirements, return rates, and operational benchmarks for direct-to-consumer brands. Sourced from Fulfyld's 3PL operations and public industry data.

28benchmark categories
50+data sources
May 2026last updated

How we calculate these benchmarks

  • Each category page carries a structured dataset built from Fulfyld's own 3PL order data plus published industry sources, 50+ across the library.
  • The figures shown are averages: average order value in USD and the category's average return rate.
  • Benchmarks are reviewed and refreshed on a rolling basis. Every card shows when its category was last updated.
  • See a number that looks off, or a source we should add? Use "Suggest a benchmark category" at the bottom of this page.

28 of 28 categories

All benchmark categories

Accessories

Huge SKU variety, poly-mailer-friendly sizes and style-driven returns.

Avg order value
$68
Return rate
15%
Updated May 2026 View accessories benchmarks

Apparel

High SKU complexity across size-color matrices, elevated returns and seasonal spikes.

Avg order value
$120
Return rate
25%
Updated May 2026 View apparel benchmarks

Automotive Parts

Massive SKU range from small sensors to 80 lb parts. Fitment errors drive returns.

Avg order value
$147
Return rate
19%
Updated May 2026 View automotive parts benchmarks

Baby Products

Strict CPSC compliance, fragile handling and subscription-friendly reorder flows.

Avg order value
$75
Return rate
10%
Updated May 2026 View baby products benchmarks

Bedding

Bulky, dim-weight-heavy parcels that reward compression packing. Elevated returns.

Avg order value
$127
Return rate
21.3%
Updated May 2026 View bedding benchmarks

Books

High-velocity, low-return media SKUs with predictable weights and holiday spikes.

Avg order value
$48
Return rate
10%
Updated May 2026 View books benchmarks

Candles

Fragile, heat-sensitive product needing careful cushioning and fire-safety labeling.

Avg order value
$53
Return rate
5%
Updated April 2026 View candles benchmarks

CBD

Evolving federal and state compliance, carrier restrictions and COA documentation.

Avg order value
$63
Return rate
7%
Updated May 2026 View CBD benchmarks

Cosmetics

Fragile glass packaging, shade-variant SKU sprawl and strict batch tracking.

Avg order value
$58
Return rate
5%
Updated April 2026 View cosmetics benchmarks

Electronics

ESD-safe handling, layered protective packaging and serial-number traceability.

Avg order value
$187
Return rate
11%
Updated May 2026 View electronics benchmarks

Fragrance

DOT flammable classification, ORM-D shipping rules and fragile glass bottles.

Avg order value
$87
Return rate
12%
Updated April 2026 View fragrance benchmarks

Furniture

Highest AOVs in ecommerce with oversized packaging and LTL freight logistics.

Avg order value
$264
Return rate
10%
Updated May 2026 View furniture benchmarks

Haircare

Fast-growing beauty segment with leak-prone liquids and subscription reorders.

Avg order value
$52
Return rate
5%
Updated April 2026 View haircare benchmarks

Home Goods

Wide weight and dimension range, from soft textiles to bulky decor pieces.

Avg order value
$253
Return rate
11.5%
Updated May 2026 View home goods benchmarks

Jewelry

High-value, small-form SKUs needing secure packaging and chain-of-custody control.

Avg order value
$195
Return rate
10%
Updated April 2026 View jewelry benchmarks

Kitchen Goods

Utensils to cast iron: a wide fragility spectrum and robust protective packaging.

Avg order value
$85
Return rate
20.4%
Updated May 2026 View kitchen goods benchmarks

Lithium Battery

Regulated hazmat with UN38.3 documentation and carrier-specific packing rules.

Avg order value
$42
Return rate
8.5%
Updated May 2026 View lithium battery benchmarks

Luxury Items

White-glove handling, signature-required delivery and premium unboxing.

Avg order value
$310
Return rate
12%
Updated May 2026 View luxury items benchmarks

Medical Equipment

FDA-compliant storage, lot-level traceability and specialized packaging.

Avg order value
$386
Return rate
8%
Updated May 2026 View medical equipment benchmarks

Nutraceuticals

Food-grade regulatory complexity with subscription-heavy consumable economics.

Avg order value
$72
Return rate
7%
Updated May 2026 View nutraceuticals benchmarks

Outdoor Equipment

Compact packs to bulky tents and kayaks, with carrier-optimized packaging.

Avg order value
$147
Return rate
12%
Updated May 2026 View outdoor equipment benchmarks

Pet Products

Fast-growing category with heavy consumables and subscription reorder cycles.

Avg order value
$72
Return rate
6.5%
Updated April 2026 View pet products benchmarks

Skincare & Beauty

FDA MoCRA registration, FEFO lot tracking and climate-controlled storage.

Avg order value
$54
Return rate
5%
Updated April 2026 View skincare & beauty benchmarks

Subscription Boxes

Predictable monthly batch cycles with multi-SKU pick-and-pack complexity.

Avg order value
$43
Return rate
5.5%
Updated May 2026 View subscription boxes benchmarks

Supplements

FDA regulatory complexity plus subscription-heavy repeat purchase cycles.

Avg order value
$65
Return rate
7%
Updated May 2026 View supplements benchmarks

Swag & Promotional Products

Kitted brand boxes, on-demand drops and bulk event shipments in one program.

Avg order value
$85
Return rate
5%
Updated May 2026 View swag & promotional products benchmarks

Toys & Games

Extreme Q4 seasonality with mandatory CPSC safety certification.

Avg order value
$188
Return rate
19.3%
Updated May 2026 View toys & games benchmarks

Wellness & Healthcare

Supplements, OTC devices and consumables, each with FDA labeling obligations.

Avg order value
$97
Return rate
8.5%
Updated May 2026 View wellness & healthcare benchmarks

Don't see your category?

We publish fresh benchmarks every month. Tell us what category you'd like to see next — or get a flat fulfillment quote based on your order volume, SKU count, and shipping needs.